PARANASAL SINUSES: ANATOMlC TERMlNOLOGY AND NOMENCLATURE
This article is adopted from Annals of Otology, Rhinology and Laryngology Suppl. 167 - Oct 1995 Vol 104, No 10, Part 2, pp7-16
Article Scanned, and Rewritten with a help of OCR system by Kyung Shik Suh, M.D., Dept. of ORL, Ajou University Hospital
EDITED BY
PROF HEINZ R. STAMMBERGER, MD
DAVID W. KENNEDY, MD
Anatomic Illustration coordinated by MAJ WILLLAM E. BOLGER, MC, USAF
FACULTY OF THE ANATOMIC TERMINOLOGY GROUP
PROF HEINZ R. STAMMBERGER, MD, FACILITATOR
MAJ WlLLlAM E. BOLGER, MC, USAF
PROF PETER A. R. CLEMENT, MD
PROF WERNER HOSEMANN, MD
FREDERICK A. KUHN, MD
DONALD C. LANZA, MD
DONALD A. LEOPOLD, MD
TOSHIO OHNISHI, MD
PROF DESIDERIO PASSALI, MD
STEVEN D. SCHAEFER, MD
PROF M. R. WAYOFF, MD
S. JAMES ZINREICH, MD
A consensus on the
preferred modem usage of potentially confusing or ambiguous temls in sinus anatomy and nomenclature is described.
These terms are intended to provide clear communication among otorhinolaryngologists and serve as a basis for discussion among anatomists. Teminology is in English and based on Latin nomenclature. An attempt has been made to reconcile or eliminate duplication, redundancy, and overlap in terminology that have arisen over the past century. A key concept is that the ethmoid complex is divided into anterior and posterior sections by the basal lamella of the middle turbinate.
KEY WORDS-ethmoid sinus, nomenclature, paranasal sinuses, sinusitis, terminology.
lNTRODUCTION
Recent advances in clinical technology, especially computed tomography (CT) and microscopic and endoscopic sinonasal surgery, have given renewed importance to the standardization of anatomic terminology in sinusitis. Current understanding of the localization and extent of the pathophysiology of sinus and skull base disease is based on detailed knowledge of anatomic structure. Because the opportunities for intervention are virtually unprecedented in their precision, it is imperative that surgeons and radiologists cornmunicate as efficiently and as accurately as possible.
Much of the confusion and variation in nomenclature and terminology, as well as some central issues in the pathophysiology of sinus disease, surround the structures related to the ethmoid sinuses.l The terminology in this article reflects preferred modern usage of important anatomic terms as recommended in the reports of the Anatomic Terminology Group, developed at the Intemational Conference on Sinus Disease: Terminology, Staging, and Therapy, held in the United States in Princeton, New Jersey, in July 1993. Kaufmann's4 "double middle turbinate"(Gedoppelte mittlere Muschel) describes the medially bent uncinate process that curves out of the middle meatus like the brim of a hat. The structure is not, however, a double middle turbinate in reality. Kaufmann' s term may be retained for its historical interest but not used in a rigorous anatomic context. The same applies to variations such as a paradoxicallycurved middle turbinate.
- The nomenclature and anatomic concepts presented for the lateral nasal wall and anterior skull base evolved over several decades and have proved to be satisfactory for endoscopic and microscopic diagnosis and surgery as well as for radiology.
- Topographic and directional instructions(such assuperior and inferior) are given relative to a standing person.
BEHIND THE CONFUSION IN ETHMOID TERMINOLOGY
Confusion and disparate practices exist today concerning the definitions and usage of such terms as hiatus semilunaris, infundibulum, frontal recess, and nasofrontal duct. It is interesting to note, however, that many of the misunderstandings date from the time when the terms were first coined. While Zuckerkandl5,6 used the term hiatus semilunaris in much the same way as we do, to signify the two-dimensional cleft between the posterior margin of the uncinate process and the anterior face of the ethmoid bulla, the term ethmoid infundibulumhas been used more loosely.
Anatomists today consider the ethmoid infundibulum to be a three-dimensional structure that is actually a well-defined cleft. Initially, however, Zuckerkandl applied the term only to the depression extending forward from the hiatus semilunaris both inferiorly and superiorly into the lateral nasal wall. He attributed the term to Boyer, even though what Boyer described was the cleft that Killian7 later called the frontal recess. Since then, others have erroneously used the terms frontal infundibulum and nasofrontal duct synonymously with frontal recess.
Additional terms for the clefts of the anterior ethmoid region have been invented and applied without regard to consistency. As a result, numerous terms have come into being for a single structure. For example, what was termed recessus frontalis by one author was called ductus nasofrontalis and recessus anterior meatus medii by later contributors to the literature. For another example, the frontal recess has been called the frontal infundibulum of the hiatus semilunaris, and the terms hiatus semilunaris and ethmoid infundibulum have been used for the same structure.
ETHMOID COMPLEXES
The structures of the lateral nasal wall and paranasal sinuses fall into two anatomically and physiologically distinct categories, the anterior and posterior ethmoidcomplexes (Fig 1) PNS1.gif. . The basal lamella of the middle turbinate is the clear and distinct separation between thetwo ethmoid complexes, according to definition, patterns of mucociliary secretion transport, and embryologic development. Cells and clefts that open and drain anteriorly and inferiorly to this lamella belong to the anterior ethmoid complex; those that open or drain posteriorly or superiorly, with the exception of the sphenoid sinus, belong to the posterior ethmoid complex. The expressions middle ethmoid and middle ethmoid cells should not be used, because in terms of anatomy, physiology, or function, no structure represents the middle of the ethmoid complex.
BASAL LAMELLA OF MIDDLE TURBINATE
This structure is actually the third basal lamella of the ethmoturbinals (Fig 2) PNS2.gif . The most anterior and superior insertion of the middle turbinate is adjacent to the crista ethmoidalis of the maxilla. The posterior end is attached to the crista ethmoidalis of the perpendicular process of the palatine bone(lamina perpendicularis).
The area between comprises three parts . The anterior third of the middle turbinate inserts vertically into the skull base at the lateral edge of the lamina cribrosa. The middle third turns laterally across the skull base to the lamina papyracea, where it turns inferiorly. The most posterior segment becomes horizontal.
The insertion of the middle turbinate thus lies in three different planes. The anterior segment lies sagittally, attaching to the lateral end of the lamina cribrosa opposite its lamina lateralis. The middle segment is fixed to the lamina papyracea in an almost frontal plane. The posterior segment is attached to the lamina papyracea, the medial wall of the maxillary sinus, or both, to form the roof of the posterior third of the middle meatus.
The stability of the middle turbinate accrues largely from its fixation along three planes. The frontal and posterior portions, which are vertical and horizontal, respectively, are part of the basal lamella of the middle turbinate. The middle section, also part of the basal lamella, is not necessarily a smooth surface. Cells or well-pneumatized clefts of the anterior ethmoid can indent this plate dorsally, giving it a posterosuperior orientation. When a retrobullar recess is well developed, anterior ethmoid cells can reach back almost to the sphenoid sinus. Conversely, cells of the posterior ethmoid or the superior meatus can create an anterior bulge in the midsection of the basal lamella.
[Discussion. The turbinates originate from the lateral nasal wall during development, and each has its own basal lamella. As the basal lamella of the third ethmoturbinal, which separates the anterior and posterior ethmoid complexes, the middle turbinate is anatomically and physiologically the most important ofthe basal larnellas. Because there is more than one basal lamella, however, when the term basal lamella is used, the turbinate with which it is associated must bespecified.
The role of the basal lamella of the middle turbinate as the division between anterior and posterior ethmoid complexes is underscored by the French terminology, racine cloisonnante du cornet moyen, which means the dividing root of the middle turbinate. The term basal is preferable to ground to avoid misnomers such as grand lamella, which lend themselves to misconceptions and confusion.]
ANTERIOR ETHMOID AND RELATED STRUCI'URES
Uncinate Process.
The term derives from the Latin, processus uncinatus, meaning hooked outgrowth, and refers to a remnant of the descending portion of the first ethmoturbinal.
The uncinate process is a thin, bony leaflet that resembles a hook (Fig 3) PNS3.gif . It is oriented almost sagittallyand runs from anterosuperior to posteroinferior. Its concave posterosuperior free margin is parallel to the anterior surface of the ethmoid bulla. The uncinate process attaches to the perpendicular process(lamina perpendicularis) of the palatine bone and the ethmoid process of the inferior turbinate with bony spicules. The convex anterior margin ascends to the lacrimal bone,and sometimes to the skull base or lamina papyracea, remaining in contact with the bony lateral nasal wall(Fig 4) PNS4.gif . When curved medially to a greater than usual extent, the free margin of the uncinate process may protrude into, and sometimes even out of, the middle nasal meatus. The uncinate process may attach to the middle turbinate superiorly, too, when curved medially in its superior most portion. In rare cases, the superior part of the uncinate process may attach with several "fingers" to the middle turbinate, the skull base, and the lateral nasal wall as well.
Agger Nasi.
The term comes from the Latin for nasal mound and refers to the most superior remnant of the first ethmoturbinal, which persists as a mound or crest immediately anterior and superior to the insertion of the middle turbinate (Fig 5) PNS5.gif . An agger nasi cell results when this area of the lateral nasal wall under goes pneumatization. Depending on the degree of pneumatization, agger nasi cells may reach laterally to the lacrimal fossa and cause narrowing of the frontal recess.
Ethmoid Bulla.
From the Latin, bulla ethmoidalis,where bulla means a hollow, thin-walled, bony prominence, the name refers to the largest and most nonvariant air cells in the anterior ethmoid complex. It is formed by pneumatization of the bulla lamella, or second ethmoid basal lamella, and is like a bleb on the lamina papyracea. The bulla lamella can form the posterior wall of the frontal recess if it reaches the roof of the ethmoid. Failure to reach the skull base, however, results information of the suprabullar recess, an aerated space of varying dimensions between the bulla lamella and the skull base.
[Discussion. The ethmoid bulla, created when the second basal lamella of the ethmoturbinals is pneumatized, is sometimes called a promontory in the literature. In the absence of pneumatization, it does not exist. The traditional anatomic term for a persisting and nonpneumatized second basal lamella is torus ethmoidalis. The suggestion to change the name torus bullaris was rejected by the Anatomic Terminology Group because the term is oxymoronic. Torus describes a solid structure, and bullaris refers to apneumatized structure. The term torus lateralis does not specifically denote the non-pneumatized bulla lamella.]
Suprabullar and Retrobullar Recess(Sinus Lateralis).
The Latin term recessus suprabullaris et retrobullaris has as synonyms the sinus lateralis of Grunwald8 and the susbullar cell of Mouret.9,l0 The suprabullar recess may extend into a retrobullar recess if the posterior wall of the bulla lamella is not in contact with the basal lamella of the middle turbinate. When well developed, this space is bordered superiorly by the ethmoid roof, laterally by the lamina papyracea, inferiorly by the roofof the ethmoid bulla, and posteriorly by the basal lamella of the middle turbinate. Anteriorly, it is separated from the frontal recess only when the bulla lamella reaches the skull base . Otherwise, the suprabullar recess opens into the frontal recess. The suprabullar and retrobullar recess also can be approached medially and inferiorly through the hiatus semilunaris superior.
[Discussion . This space does not have a single openingfor ventilation and drainage, and therefore does notsatisfy the criteria of a cell. The term recess is recommended because the space can be approached anteriorly and superiorly from the frontal recess and medially and inferiorly from the hiatus semilunaris superior. Grunwald's term, sinus lateralis, is suitable anatomically, but the complete term, sinus lateralis sinus ethmoidalis, is necessary to differentiate it from the lateral sinus in the brain. The latter term is considered too long to be practical.]
Hiatus Semilunaris Inferior.
The origin of this termis the hiatus semilunaris inferior of Grunwald.8 The hiatus semilunaris inferior is an anatomic plane that represents the shortest distance between the free posterior margin of the uncinate process and the corresponding anterior face of the ethmoid bulla. Typically, but not necessarily, it lies in the sagittal plane and does not represent a true space (Fig 3) PNS3.gif .
Two concepts are helpful when considering the term hiatus semilunaris. First, the Latin root translates directly into English as cleft, gap, or passageway; indeed, the hiatus semilunaris inferior is a crescent-shaped cleft. Second, the passageway is like a doorway through which one must pass to arrive at the ethmoid infundibulum, which is a three-dimensional space. Hiatus Semilunaris Superior. This is a second, but only vaguely defined, crescent-shaped cleft between the ethmoid bulla and the middle turbinate. The suprabullar and retrobullar recess can be entered medially and inferiorly underneath the middle turbinate through the hiatus semilunaris superior.
[Discussion. The term inferior rather than anterior is recornmended for the hiatus semilunaris that is located between the uncinate process and the ethmoid bulla,and superior rather than posterior is recommended for the hiatus semilunaris that may lead into the suprabullar and retrobullar recess. When the orientation of the head conforms to that of a standing person, inferior and superior are more accurate.]
Infundibulum.
The term infundibulum (plural, infundibula) connotes a funnel shaped structure and comes from the Latin infundere, meaning to pour into. There are three different infundibula in the paranasal sinuses: the frontal, maxillary, and ethmoid. The ethmoid infundibulum is the most important pathophysiologically, and the others are notable primarily for historical perspective. The ethmoid infundibulurn, from infundibulum ethmoidale, is a cleft or true three-dimensional space. Were a cast made of the space, it would typically resemble an inverted segment of grapefruit with the wide edge facing posteriorly.
The ethmoid infundibulum is bordered medially by the uncinate process and laterally by the lamina papyracea. The frontal process of the maxilla and the lacrimal bone may constitute parts of the lateral wall anterosuperiorly, but this is rare. Fusion with the anterior border of the uncinate process provides a connection with the inferior turbinate.
At its anterior end, the ethmoid infundibulum ends blindly in an acute angle, giving rise to the V-like shape noted in axial sections and on CT scans. Posteriorly, the ethmoid infundibulum extends to the anterior face of the ethmoid bulla and opens into the middle meatus through the hiatus semilunaris inferior. Periosteum and mucous membrane cover bony defects in the lateral nasal wall, forming the anterior and posterior nasal fontanelles.
The maxillary sinus ostium usually can be found at the floor and lateral aspect of the infundibulum between its middle and posterior third. From the middle meatus, the natural ostium of the maxillary sinus therefore remains hidden, lateral to the uncinate process in the ethmoid infundibulum.
The relationship between the ethmoid infimdibulum and the skull base, especially the frontal recess, depends on the uncinate process. Superiorly, the ethmoid infundibulum may end blindly in the terminal recess, or recessus terminalis, if the uncinate process bends laterally and inserts onto the lamina papyracea. If the uncinate process reaches to the skull base or fuses with the middle turbinate medially, the ethmoid infundibulum may pass into the frontal recess superiorly.
[Discussion. The frontal sinus and maxillary sinus infundibula are inside their respective sinus cavities and resemble narrowing or funneling tunnels toward their natural ostia. The border between the ethmoid infundibulum and the frontal recess is difficult to define. Embryologically, the ethmoid infundibulum and frontal recess arose from a single structure, and the variations of the uncinate process determine the relationship between the two in maturity.]
The frontal infundibulum, named from the Latin infundibulum sinus frontalis or infundibulum frontale, is a funnel-shaped narrowing of the inferior aspect ofthe frontal sinus toward the floor of the frontal sinus ostium. It is located inside the frontal sinus. The maxillary infundibulum, after the Latin infundibulum sinus maxillaris or infundibulum maxillare, is the funnel-shaped narrowing of the lumen of the maxillary sinus toward its natural ostium. Typically, the lumen does not narrow significantly toward the maxillary sinus ostium.
Frontal Recess.
Perhaps the most complicated structure in the anterior ethmoid complex, the frontal recessis the most anterior and superior portion of the complex that leads to and communicates with the frontal sinus (Fig 5) PNS5.gif . It is not synonymous with the nasofrontal duct.
The medial wall of the frontal recess is the most anterior and superior part of the middle turbinate. The lateral wall is mostly lamina papyracea. A discrete posterior margin exists only when the basal lamella ofthe bulla reaches the skull base, separating the frontal recess from the suprabullar recess . If the insertion of the bulla lamella reaches far anteriorly and/or the bulla is well pneumatized, the frontal recess becomes narrowed from the posterior. This may result in a tubular appearance on sagittal section, which is the reason the narrowed recess came to be known, albeit incorrectly, as the nasofrontal duct. Under certain conditions, a tubular structure can be the communication between the frontal recess and the frontal sinus.
In sagittal section, the frontal recess usually has the shape of an inverted funnel. When taken together withthe frontal infundibulum, the shape resembles an hourglass, with the constricted portion being at the level of the natural ostium of the frontal sinus. The floor of the frontal recess varies so much that it has no uniform definition.
[Discussion. Although the anatomic definitions are clear, there is great confusion in usage among these terms. The frontal recess is the most anterior and superior part of the anterior ethmoid complex. From here, the frontal bone becomes pneumatized, resulting in a frontal sinus. Seen from above, the frontal recess narrows toward its ostium (through the frontal infundibulum). From the level of the ostium, the frontal recess then widens in the inferior and posterior direction, usually in the shape of an inverted funnel.
When this communication is narrowed from behind by the ethmoid bulla or the bulla lamella or from in front by a pneumatized agger nasi cell,a short, ductlike structure results. The bony walls of the resulting structure are not truly its own, however, so to call it a duct or other tubular structure is not anatomically correct. Its ductlike appearance on sagittal or coronal CT scans is misleading.
The formation of additional cells in the frontal recess and the infundibulum, apart from agger nasi cells, is highly individual. The Anatomic Terminology Group recommends that they be described according to their anatomic orientation. For example, if they reach the lacrimal sac and pneumatize into the lacrimal bone, they would be lacrimal cells of the ethmoid infundibulum or lacrimal cells of the frontal recess. A cell that pneumatizes into the frontal bone is likewise a frontal cell of the anterior ethmoid or a bulla frontalis. Terms such as threshold cell are to be avoided. A supraorbital cell is an anatomic variant that develops as an extension, from the posterior aspect, of the frontal or suprabullar recess. It is therefore called a supraorbital cell of the frontal recess or a supraorbital cell of the suprabullar recess.]
Nasal Fontanelles.
These are the areas of the lateral nasal wall in which no bone exists. They are usually found immediately above the insertion of the inferior turbinate. Thus, the mucosa of the maxillary sinus and the middle meatus are separated only by a fibrous layer of periosteum. The fontanelles may be sites of accessory ostia to the maxillary sinus. The anterior fontanelleis inferior and anterior to the uncinate process; the posterior fontanelle is superior and posterior to the part of the uncinate process that fuses with the medial wall of the maxillary sinus.
Roof of Ethmoid.
Lateral to the lamina cribrosa and to the inserlion of the middle turbinate, the ethmoid bone is open superiorly. The ethmoid roof itself is created by the frontal bone. Indentations or foveolae in the frontal bone cover the corresponding clefts and cells ofthe ethmoid.
Keros11 has described three different and surgically important types of configurations of the ethmoid roof(Fig 6) PNS6.gif . The differentiation depends on the length of thelateral lamella of the cribriform plate, which is the thinnest bone in the entire anterior skull base.l2 In type 1, the olfactory fossa is only 1 to 3 mm deep, the lateral lamella is short (almost nonexistent), and the ethmoid roof is almost in the same plane as the cribriform plate. In type 2, the olfactory fossa is from 4 to 7 mm deep, andthe lateral lamella is longer. In type 3, the olfactory fossais 8 to 16 mm deep, and the ethmoid roof lies significantly above the cribriform plate. Because of the danger that instrumentation can penetrate the thin and vulnerable lateral lamella, this is the configuration of greatest concern for the surgeon.
[Discussion. Controversy surrounds the terms fovea and foveolae ethmoidales. The anterior two thirds of the ethmoid complex opens superiorly, and the cells and clefts in this area are closed over by the frontal bone. Small pits or indentations overlie the open ethmoid clefts and spaces, which are open superiorly. These indentations are the foveolae (from the Latin, foveolae ethmoidales ossis frontalis, meaning ethmoid pits of the frontal bone). Use of the term fovea for the entire ethmoid roof doesnot distinguish between the endonasal view and the view from above looking down on the olfactory groove. While any individual pit may be called a fovea or foveola, the ethmoid roof may not. The Anatomic Terminology Group recommends that only the term foveolae ethmoidales(of the frontal bone) be used and advises that the terms fovea and dome of the ethmoid not be used. The clinical significance of the Keros classification accrues from the fact that the risk of intracranial entry during surgery increases with the length and, consequently, angulation of the lateral lamella of the cribriform plate. When a patient has a type 3 configuration,perhaps 14to 16mm of anterior cranial fossa is medial to a place where instrumentation may be used.]
Concha Bullosa.
When there is pneumatization of the middle turbinate, the term concha bullosa is used. The term may also apply to pneumatization of the superior turbinate. The pneumatization of the middle turbinate usually originates from the frontal recess or the agger nasi, and growth of a concha bullosa may begin late in life.
[Discussion. The concha bullosa must be distinguished from an interlamellar cell (Fig 7) PNS7.gif , which arises from pneumatization of the vertical lamella of the middle turbinate from the superior meatus . The concha bullosa is a normal variant that in itself does not require surgery, but the presence of a concha bullosa may predispose a patient to occlusion of the ostiomeatal complex and subsequent sinus disease. Therefore, surgery may be appropriate.]
Infraorbital Ethmoid Cell (Haller's Cell).
The potential pathophysiologic importance of a Haller' s cell is clear, but the anatomic definition is not. As described by Haller in 1765, these cells grow into the bony orbital floor that constitutes the roof of the maxillary sinus, are differentiable from the bulla, and have a potential pathophysiologic relationship to a narrowed ethmoid infundibulum or maxillary sinus ostium (Fig 8) PNS8.gif .
The term cellula orbitoethmoidalis or orbitoethmoidcell does not indicate, for example, that the cell grows directly into the floor of the orbit. The term infraorbitalethmoid cell is better because it implies contrast with a supraorbital cell that originates from the frontal or suprabullar recess. For exactitude, the full term is infraorbital cell of the anterior or posterior ethmoids, depending on its origin.
Ostiomeatal Complex.
No consensus exists to define exact anatomic descriptions of the borders and margins of the ostiomeatal complex.l3 Rather, the ostiomeatal complex is a functional entity of the anterior ethmoid complex that represents the final common pathway for drainage and ventilation of the frontal, maxillary, and anterior ethmoid cells (Fig 9) PNS9.gif . Any or all cells, clefts, and ostia, with their dependent sinuses, may become diseased, thereby contributing to the symptoms and pathophysiology of sinusitis.
POSTERIOR ETHMOID AND RELATED STRUCTURES
Posterior Ethmoid and Sphenoid Sinus .
There are only a few terms in anatomic nomenclature that require a better definition and explanation in these regions.
Like the middle turbinate, the superior and, if present, supreme turbinates are attached to the lateral nasal wall and the anterior skull base by means of their basal lamellas. The course of attachment of the supreme turbinate is similar to that of the middle turbinate but of less significance in pathophysiology and surgery. The superior nasal meatus (meatus nasi superior) and supreme nasal meatus(meatus nasi supremus) lie underneath the respective turbinates. Because the individual cells and clefts underneath the supreme(or fourth) turbinate are nowhere defined in the literature, they are considered part of a single posterior ethmoid complex.
The sphenoethmoid recess (recessus sphenoethmoidalis) is the space between the superior (and supreme, if present) turbinate laterally, the roof of the nose(rima olfactoria) superiorly, and the nasal septum medially. Its posterior border is the anterior face of the sphenoid bone. Medially there is no clearcut inferior border, and laterally the inferior border is seen at the inferior margin of the superior turbinate. The anterior extension is equally ill-defined, passing into the common nasal meatus.
Sphenoethmoid Cell.
Posterior ethmoid cells can become pneumatized far laterally and to some degree superiorly to the sphenoid sinus, in which case they are called sphenoethmoid cells(cellulae sphenoethmoidales) or Onodi cells (Fig 10) PNS10.gif . Pneumatization of the clinoid process in those cases may originate from the posterior ethmoid cell, also.
The optic nerve and carotid artery may be exposed in a sphenoethmoid(Onodi) cell. This is clinically significant because the sphenoid sinus is located medially and inferiorly to the most posterior cell of the posteriorethmoid complex. Consequently, attempts to use instrumentation to locate the sphenoid sinus directly behind the last cell of the posterior ethmoid complex may result in serious damage to the optic nerve or carotid artery.
[Discussion. The most posterior ethmoid cell may becalled a sphenoethmoid cell(Onodi cell) when it pneumatizes laterally and superiorly to the sphenoid sinus and is intimately associated with the optic nerve. Prominence of the optic nerve tubercle or the internal carotid artery is not prerequisite, however. Moreover, the optic nerve tubercle may be prominent in other posterior ethmoid cells as well. Whether ethmoid complex components grow posteriorly alongside the sphenoid sinus or sphenoethmoid cells pneumatize directly into the sphenoid bone has not been resolved, but the answer does not bear on practical issues in diagnosis and sugery: the air space in question isclearly ethmoid.]
Optic Nerve Tubercle.
The bulge of the medial aspect of the bone surrounding the optic foramen (foramen opticum) is the optic nerve tubercle (tuberculum nervi optici) . Depending on the degree of pneumatization and the presence and configuration of sphenoethmoid cells, it can be seen in the posterior ethmoid cells, at the transition between the posterior ethmoid and sphenoid sinuses, or in the sphenoid sinus itself. The optic canal (canalis opticus) can project into the sinus lumen, and dehiscences of the bony wall may be present. The optic nerve may pass through a sphenoethmoid cell or sphenoid sinus like a column, surrounded by pneumatized space. There may be an infraoptic recess between the opticnerve and the intemal carotid artery. The more pronounced the pneumatization of the anterior clinoid process, the deeper the recess.
EMBRYOLOGY OF BONY LATERAL NASAL WALL
Understanding the embryologic development of the turbinates and the ethmoid sheds light on the complex relationships involving the basal lamella. The ethmoid turbinates form on the lateral nasal wall of the fetus, giving rise to six ridges during the 9th and 10th weeks of fetal development. These typically fuse into fewer ridges, which become clearly separated by furrows. Like mature turbinates, each ridge and furrow has an anterior ascending and a posterior descending portion.
During development, the first ethmoturbinal regresses and does not become permanent. The descending portion of the first ethmoturbinal remains as the uncinate process,and the ascending portion remains asthe agger nasi (ie, the nasoturbinal). The middle and posterior sections of the depression between the first and second ethmoturbinals(the descending portion) become the ethmoid infundibulum, and the superior ascending part becomes the frontal recess. The frontal sinus is formed by pneumatization of the frontal recess into the frontal bone. The inferior turbinate, known as the maxilloturbinal, is a single bone unrelated to the ethmoturbinals.
From these embryologic relationships, one can see that the uncinate process is actually the basal lamella of the first ethmoturbinal. Similarly, the ethmoid bulla evolves from the second basal lamella, and the middle turbinate from the third basal lamella.
Given the variety of anatomic features of an ethmoid cell, the only fixed point of reference is the ostium. Thus, cells are classified as belonging to the anterior ethmoid when they drain into the middle meatus and belonging to the posterior ethmoid when they drain into the superior meatus.
The phrases ethmoid cells of the middle meatus and ethmoid cells of the superior meatus may be more strictly correct than the terms anterior ethmoid sinus and posterior ethmoid sinus, which are currently in use. Such a major change in nomenclature, however, could be confusing. Therefore, we continue to use the terms anterior ethmoid and posterior ethmoid and designate the basal lamella of the middle turbinate as their separation.
CONCLUSION
The Anatomic Temlinology Group's suggestions for a unified system of terminology are designed to provide a current intenational language for otorhinolaryngologic surgeons and to serve as a basis for discussion among anatomists. The Group plans to renew its discussions of anatomic terminology and nomenclaturein 1997.
REFERENCES